Shadow Minister for Fisheries Kirrilee Warr MLA has questioned how the Fisheries Minister can confidently establish a Kalbarri fishing zone by 2028, saying key data the Minister relied upon to make these decisions may not be available as a result of the demersal fishing ban.
It comes following an ABC report on Thursday saying fishers did not believe the research underpinning their industry is up to standard amid a transition to quota management.
Previously, the Department of Primary Industries and Regional Development (DPIRD) has relied on data from the commercial fishing sector to determine stock levels.
Ms Warr said during Budget Estimates, it was confirmed that no formal stock assessment would take place in 2026 in the West Coast Bioregion.
“The Opposition asked questions around stock assessments and how data would be collected, and we were told there would be no formal stock assessments taking place this year,” she said.
“It is hypocritical of the Minister to close an industry based on the science but then decide to reopen the fishery based on the data. How can you manage something you are not measuring?
“This is a continuation of what we see from the Cook Labor Government: policy without a plan.”
Ms Warr said the Minister is happy to throw the Western Australian Fishing Industry Council (WAFIC) under the bus, despite the commercial sector proposing quota management years ago.
“Too often we see this Government act first, then ask questions later,” she said.
“The Minister blamed WAFIC and pitted the commercial sector against recreational fishers instead of bringing groups together to find a solution.
“The Minister’s own advisory group lacks a voice from the commercial sector, who could provide valuable insight into how a managed system could operate going forward.”
Ms Warr said there needed to be an explanation for the additional budget funding for fishing data.
“We have been told there is $5m budgeted for an ‘enhanced science program’ in the State Budget, but there is little detail provided to what this means,” she said.
“Why won’t the minister explain the program and how it will help assess demersal fish stocks?”
The Western Australian fisheries portfolio has become an absolute shambles under Labor, with three different Ministers in the past decade delivering shifting policies while funding for fisheries management, research and development has been repeatedly cut.
“Fisheries management must be based on sound science and evidence not political expediency, or the latest policy direction of whichever Minister happens to hold the portfolio.
“At the 2025 State Election, The Nationals WA made a clear commitment to return Fisheries to a standalone department with appropriate funding, ensuring fisheries management is properly underpinned by science and research.
“After a decade of Labor’s mismanagement, it is clear the current approach is not working.
“Labor simply cannot be trusted to properly manage Western Australia’s fisheries resources.”